3 is everywhere - Numberphile

Numberphile · 2.9M views · 2012 · 6:33

Open on YouTube

Recreational & visual mathProbability & game theoryexplainer

Why Mathematics Stack Exchange recommends it

Mathematics Stack Exchange users cite it as the source of the "3 is everywhere" claim whenever they ask about its proof, its limit argument, or density of infinite sets.

Recommended by 1 people across 1 different months, 2014 to 2018.

What it is

A short Numberphile video in which Dr James Grime argues that almost all natural numbers contain the digit 3, by counting numbers below 10^n that avoid it (9^n of them) and showing the fraction containing a 3 tends to 1. It is an accessible introduction to the idea of natural density.

What people said

Recommends QBrute · 2015-07 · Mathematics Stack Exchange · on “Frazzle game question”

There is a really nice Numberphile video on [this video] , where he talks about occurrences of digits in numbers, which is directly related :)

Cites v010dya · 2014-08 · Mathematics Stack Exchange · on “Comparing density of countable infinite sets by examining the association”

The two questions that i am asking are in bold. To be clear, i am talking about whole number here. Having seen 3 is everywhere by Numberphile [this video] that shows that almost 100% of the whole the numbers have the digit three in them, i have been thinking of approaching the same problem from the different perspective: We have the following method of generating numbers with 3: Take any whole number without digit 3, add 3 to the left of it, and then keep adding whatever digits to the left of that 3 for as long as you want. What this tells me is that i can generate infinite amount of numbers with 3 for each one number without 3. I can then trivially show that each infinite set of numbers with 3 w

Cites Crostul · 2016-03 · Mathematics Stack Exchange · on “On the theorem "$3$ is everywhere"”

In this Numberphile video [this video] it is stated that "almost all natural numbers have the digit $3$ in their decimal representation", and a proof of this fact is proposed. A sketch of the proof follows: Denote by $D_3$ the set of natural numbers having a digit $3$ in their decimal representation. For all $n \ge 1$, denote by $$f(n) = | D_3 \cap \{ 1, \dots , n\} |$$ it is proved that for all $n$ $$f(10^n) = 10^n- 9^n $$ holds (and this is quite clear), hence $$\lim_{n \to + \infty} \frac{f(10^n)}{10^n} = 1$$ and this concludes the proof in the video. Now, this proof is clear and evident to me, but I think that it is incomplete, since we should prove that $$\lim_{n \to + \infty} \frac{f(n)}{n}

Cites ruby duby · 2016-08 · Mathematics Stack Exchange · on “How can the probability that a number contains the digit 3 be 1?”

Based on this Numberphile video [this video] which claims almost all integers contain a $3$, I have a few questions on the reasoning behind recurring decimal numbers like $0.9999\ldots =1$ What they have shown is that $$\lim_{n \to + \infty} \frac{10^n-9^n}{10^n} = 1$$ this basically means that probability of eg. a $3$ occurring in a set of numbers like for $1-10, 1-100,$ increases as the upper bound gets large. So you are more likely to see a $3$ when you take $1-100000$, than $1-10$ as the probability gets higher. So what I would like to know is as '$n$' approaches $∞$ does probability of seeing a '$3$' equals $0.99999....$? But since $0.9999... = 1$ wouldn't this not make sense, since there ar

Cites Truth-seek · 2018-02 · Mathematics Stack Exchange · on “Prove $10^{n+1} - 9^{n+1} = 9^n + 9^{n-1}10 + 9^{n-2}10^2 + ... + 10^n$”

In this video [this video] , James Grime shows that the number of $\mathbb{N}$ less than $10^{n+1}$ that have at least one $3$ among their digits is given by this recurrence relation: $$T_{n+1} = 9T_{n} + 10^{n}\; where\; T_0=1$$ But later in the video, he says it can also be written as: $$T_n = 10^{n+1} - 9^{n+1}$$ So, I set out to prove they are the same algebraically: Solving the recurrence relation, I got: $$T_n = 9^n + 9^{n-1}10 + 9^{n-2}10^2 + ... + 10^n$$ So, can somebody show me a proof to show that: $$10^{n+1} - 9^{n+1} = 9^n + 9^{n-1}10 + 9^{n-2}10^2 + ... + 10^n$$