The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class with Elizabeth Warren
Why Hacker News recommends it
HN cites it often in debates on inequality, cost disease and stagnant middle-class income, praising its data-driven approach.
What it is
Elizabeth Warren's 2007 Berkeley lecture, when she was a Harvard law professor, on why middle-class families are under growing financial strain. She draws on bankruptcy research to examine rising costs of housing, health care and education.
Recommended by 10 HN commenters across 10 different months, 2008 to 2022.
What Hacker News said
Strong rec JackC · 2012-05 · on “TED and inequality: The real story”
This is a great point. Not to get political myself, but if you compare this talk to Elizabeth Warren's "The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class"[1] from a few years back, it's night and day. Before she made economic claims, she described her exhaustive process with government agencies to get reliable data; the ways she tested the data when it seemed implausible; the various theories she tested and rejected to explain the data ... it's gripping stuff, because she develops insights based on research and hard-nosed science. That's what TED should be about. [1] [this video]
Strong rec hannibal5 · 2013-09 · on “Median Family Income Is Lower Today Than in 1989”
Elizabeth Warren has answers: The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class with Elizabeth Warren [this video] Everyone should watch the video. She answers for the question of having more cars etc.
Recommends timnic · 2008-05 · on “After the boomers, meet the children dubbed 'baby losers'”
I was watching a video by Elizabeth Warren of Harvard Law School on the topic the other day. The gist of it is (I think) basically that housing and healthcare are taking up most of the money of the middle class. In the 1970-ties a single earner could bring in enough money to support the whole family. Now in the middle class both parents have to work, which doubles the financial risk for the family if one of them (for example) looses a job. If you are interested: the link is [this video]
Recommends johnohara · 2010-06 · on “David Harvey: Crises of Capitalism (RSA Animate)”
In 2007, before the financial crisis and before becoming Chairman of the Congressional Oversight Panel investigating the Troubled Assets Relief Program, Dr. Elizabeth Warren gave a very interesting talk at UC Berkeley titled "The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class." [this video] At the time I thought it was a little alarmist, but in view of recent developments I recommend watching it (58 minutes, sorry). It speaks directly to the point about wages and how middle class households employ revolving credit to make up the the difference. The graphs and data are interesting.
Recommends patdennis · 2012-07 · on “Looting: The Economic Underworld of Bankruptcy for Profit”
This is very interesting. I think it's also worth pointing out that the data tends to show that the use of personal bankruptcy to game the system is actually very low. I find that when the subject is brought up in a political context, this distinction is often not made. Here is a great lecture from Elizabeth Warren on the subject: [this video]
Recommends eli_gottlieb · 2013-01 · on “Recession, tech kill middle-class jobs”
I'd advise giving this a watch. The data has surprised everyone, including the people researching it: [this video]
Recommends heurist · 2016-01 · on “Economic Inequality”
It's more complicated than that. You need to live in a cheap part of town to afford rent but your city is un-walkable and has poor public transportation? Buy or lease a car so you can reliably get to work on time. You have a family and want to send your children to the best (or even decent) public schools? Live in a more expensive area - you have to buy access to good schools in many places, and the monthly payment on a mortgage for a house is cheaper than renting. You want a college education? Pay up. You want health care? Better have good insurance. There are many reasons that people have debt, and it's not all exorbitant spending. At the same time SOMEONE is profiting off that debt, and t
Recommends sn9 · 2016-09 · on “A disaster is looming for American men”
This 2008 talk by Elizabeth Warren shows how much more complicated the situation is than the picture you paint. [this video]