Why Trains are so Expensive

What Hacker News said

Recommends djsumdog · 2017-04 · on “How the Airlines Became Cartels”

There's a good Wendover video on airline classes: [LINK] And another great one about AmTrak in relation to flight: [this video]

Recommends MrFoof · 2018-01 · on “California bullet train cost surges by $2.8B”

There's a lot of reasons as to why this is the case, but the bulk of it is labor. * Trains ultimately require close to 1 staff member per 4 passengers, much more than a budget airline. * Unions and legacy salaries further add to those personnel costs. The average Amtrak employee ($75K/yr) nearly makes as much as the average commercial pilot ($77K/yr). * Since train journeys take longer, the labor cost per trip is considerably higher, especially for long haul routes. When you're doing a long trip like Chicago to Los Angeles, a train takes a lot longer than a plane, so you're paying for yet more labor for that trip. 44 hours of labor for the train versus 4 hours for the plane. There's a good v

Recommends pocketstar · 2018-04 · on “Want airline food? Take Amtrak”

I understand the root issues is Amtrack unions. Amtrack staffing is one employee to four passengers. I dont know what the ratio is for airlines but it must be lower. This video does a pretty good explonation i think: [this video]

Recommends rdl · 2018-04 · on “Want airline food? Take Amtrak”

Also because it's so slow. You're tying up a lot of personnel on the train, as well as capital equipment, for multiple days, rather than hours for a plane. With the same personnel (which cost about as much as pilots/cabin crew), you could run ~10 equivalent flights. Capital equipment is cheaper for rail than in the air, but the portion of rail capex/opex (either directly, or usually via fees to freight lines) is also high. This video is a good analysis. [this video]

Recommends MaulingMonkey · 2020-02 · on “More emphasis on trains in Europe to replace flights”

> I really don't get why trains can be so expensive and what we need to do to fix that. I recently watched [this video] which covered much of the cost breakdowns - especially for American passenger rail. TL;DR: * Labor is expensive. That 10 hour train ride is 10 hours you're paying every employee on the train. The faster speed of an equivalent plane ride means you're not paying pilots for as long, or allows them to make more trips. * Rail is expensive. You have to buy the land between point A and point B. You have to build the rails, bridges, crossing guards, with lots of labor to build and maintain it all, with plenty of regulatory burdens to work through (ecological, safety, eminent domain, ...

Cites matejn · 2021-04 · on “French lawmakers approve a ban on short domestic flights”

Your question reminds me of this video by Wendover Productions: Why Trains are so Expensive: [this video] (12m38s)

Cites chrisbolt · 2022-04 · on “Europe is investing heavily in trains”

Part of the reason that Amtrak is expensive is that it's so slow. For a flight from Chicago to Seattle you only need to pay pilots/flight attendants/etc for around 5 hours of work, whereas for Amtrak it's 46 hours or more. Wendover Productions goes into detail: [this video]