Black Hat 2013 - OPSEC Failures of Spies

HackersOnBoard · 229K views · 2013 · 25:11

Open on YouTube

Security & hackingPrivacy, surveillance & cybercrimetalk

Why Hacker News recommends it

HN commenters cite it as a compelling demonstration that metadata identifies people, and as a great watch on sloppy CIA tradecraft.

What it is

Matthew Cole's Black Hat 2013 talk on operational security failures by CIA operatives. It covers the Abu Omar case and how sloppy tradecraft with cell phones exposed officers through call records and metadata.

Recommended by 2 HN commenters across 2 different months, 2014 to 2019.

What Hacker News said

Strong rec _nullandnull_ · 2014-10 · on “Troubling Arguments from the Government in Smith v. Obama”

> Call Detail Records Don’t Actually Identify People This is one of the best videos I have ever seen countering this argument. [this video]

Recommends guitarbill · 2019-08 · on “Why the CIA Doesn't Spy on the UAE”

who could forget the Abu Omar Case, where the CIA kidnapped an individual in Milan. but they left evidence due to sloppy OPSEC. so we know for sure they used to do much worse. I guess most spying activities don't warrant such a detailed investigation though, so we never find out. the Black Hat 2013 talk on this is a great watch: [this video]

Cites godgod · 2015-10 · on “CIA Director John Brennan emails”

While not a talk by Applebaum, this video is semi-related and showing OPSEC failures by CIA using cell technology: [this video]

Cites keehun · 2019-09 · on “Facebook launches Portal TV, a $149 video chat set-top box”

What none of the privacy-related prose defense by Facebook addresses is the abundant value of the metadata that Facebook will be able to harvest. Check out what leaking even just the metadata can tell about you.[0] [0]: [this video]